Finger Lakes Bed & Breakfast at Hutton Farm

Handcrafted hospitality on seven quiet acres near Keuka Lake in the heart of the Finger Lakes. 

4.7
SHARE Share VISIT WEBSITE EMAIL

Handcrafted hospitality on seven quiet acres near Keuka Lake in the heart of the Finger Lakes. 

4.7
Finger Lakes Bed & Breakfast at Hutton Farm, where a historic home and seven private acres create a place to slow down and breathe.
A table set in our 1800s home, ready to welcome you as generations have before.
Breakfast here isn’t just served—it’s curated, warmed by morning light and made to feel like home
A wraparound porch made for lingering, just as it has for generations.
Seven private acres wrapped around a home that welcomes you in
Seven private acres wrapped around a home that welcomes you in
Finger Lakes Bed & Breakfast at Hutton Farm, where a historic home and seven private acres create a place to slow down and breathe.
A table set in our 1800s home, ready to welcome you as generations have before.
Breakfast here isn’t just served—it’s curated, warmed by morning light and made to feel like home
A vase of soft blooms resting on a lace‑draped table in the quiet parlor of Finger Lakes Bed and Breakfast at Hutton Farm.
A historic dining room with a long wooden table, carved chairs, and soft daylight warming the timeless details.
A welcoming porch with soft seating, hanging flowers, and gentle light drifting in from a quiet tree‑lined street.
A richly colored historic guest room with an ornate wooden bed, vintage furnishings, and soft light warming the space.
Our main staircase and first‑floor king, where the character of our 1800s home comes into view.
A parlor layered with history, light, and the easy comfort of our 1800s home.
A parlor that holds the easy grace of our 1800s home.
We grow our own roses here, right on our little patch of Finger Lakes soil
Our roses grow right here at Hutton Farm, their blooms tucked throughout the B&B like little love notes
Pieces collected over generations, settling into the rooms as naturally as the light.
A quiet corner where sunlight and old‑soul charm meet
A beautiful Keuka Lake sunset, painted in fire and quiet magic
A real peony, grown right here and every bit as tender as the memories it carries.
And peonies we craft by hand, shaped petal by petal with the same tenderness
My fresh lemon scones, bright and tender, glazed while still warm from the oven
My Oma’s pastry, buttery and delicate, perfect beside a cup of our house‑blend coffee.”
My farm‑fresh quiche, made with eggs and bacon from our local farm partners
Our Concord grapes have grown here for well over a century, tended without a single chemical in their lifetime
Our fresh tomatoes, picked straight from the vine and carried right into your breakfast.
Wildlife is part of daily life here—turkeys included.
And this big guy returns every season, one of the many wild neighbors who treat our land like home
A cardinal—proof that some things don’t need an introduction to be adored.
Snapdragons—little bursts of color that refuse to be anything but bold
Finger Lakes fall doesn’t whisper; it erupts—color on the hills, gold in the vines, and the lake sending up its own kind of magic.
Prosciutto and melon, served on plates old enough to have outlived generations—some from the 1800s—because beauty tastes different when it’s carried on history.
128 South Ave Penn Yan, NY 14527 315-536-8070
SHARE Share VISIT WEBSITE EMAIL
EXPLORE
Seven private acres wrapped around a home that welcomes you in
Finger Lakes Bed & Breakfast at Hutton Farm, where a historic home and seven private acres create a place to slow down and breathe.
A table set in our 1800s home, ready to welcome you as generations have before.
Breakfast here isn’t just served—it’s curated, warmed by morning light and made to feel like home
A vase of soft blooms resting on a lace‑draped table in the quiet parlor of Finger Lakes Bed and Breakfast at Hutton Farm.
A historic dining room with a long wooden table, carved chairs, and soft daylight warming the timeless details.
A welcoming porch with soft seating, hanging flowers, and gentle light drifting in from a quiet tree‑lined street.
A richly colored historic guest room with an ornate wooden bed, vintage furnishings, and soft light warming the space.
Our main staircase and first‑floor king, where the character of our 1800s home comes into view.
A parlor layered with history, light, and the easy comfort of our 1800s home.
A parlor that holds the easy grace of our 1800s home.
We grow our own roses here, right on our little patch of Finger Lakes soil
Our roses grow right here at Hutton Farm, their blooms tucked throughout the B&B like little love notes
Pieces collected over generations, settling into the rooms as naturally as the light.
A quiet corner where sunlight and old‑soul charm meet
A beautiful Keuka Lake sunset, painted in fire and quiet magic
A real peony, grown right here and every bit as tender as the memories it carries.
And peonies we craft by hand, shaped petal by petal with the same tenderness
My fresh lemon scones, bright and tender, glazed while still warm from the oven
My Oma’s pastry, buttery and delicate, perfect beside a cup of our house‑blend coffee.”
My farm‑fresh quiche, made with eggs and bacon from our local farm partners
Our Concord grapes have grown here for well over a century, tended without a single chemical in their lifetime
Our fresh tomatoes, picked straight from the vine and carried right into your breakfast.
Wildlife is part of daily life here—turkeys included.
And this big guy returns every season, one of the many wild neighbors who treat our land like home
A cardinal—proof that some things don’t need an introduction to be adored.
Snapdragons—little bursts of color that refuse to be anything but bold
Finger Lakes fall doesn’t whisper; it erupts—color on the hills, gold in the vines, and the lake sending up its own kind of magic.
Prosciutto and melon, served on plates old enough to have outlived generations—some from the 1800s—because beauty tastes different when it’s carried on history.

BOOK NOW

The Basics

SELECT REGISTRY MEMBER SINCE 1/1/2026

Finger Lakes Bed & Breakfast rests on seven quiet acres just south of Keuka Lake, where an 1840s farmhouse welcomes guests with warmth, history, and unhurried charm. Mornings begin with a homemade breakfast, evenings drift into porch‑light ease, and every room blends antique character with thoughtful comfort. This is where the Finger Lakes slows down for you.

At a Glance

  • Free WiFi
  • Adult Only
  • Hot Breakfast
  • History & Heritage
  • Gardens
  • Outdoor Activities
  • Romantic Getaway
  • Wine/Vineyard

In the Know

  • Spotted Duck serves farm‑fresh custard made with duck eggs-a local obsession and completely worth the short drive.

  • Explore the Keuka Outlet Trail for quiet waterfalls, old mill ruins, and forest stretches that feel miles from everything.

  • Spend a Saturday at The Windmill, a Finger Lakes favorite packed with local artisans, baked goods, and handmade finds. 

  • Try Birds Eye Hollow's smooth maple bourbon and fresh maple‑bacon pizza for a true taste of this local favorite.

Finger Lakes Bed & Breakfast at Hutton Farm, where a historic home and seven private acres create a place to slow down and breathe.

Stay for the Story

On seven serene acres near Keuka Lake, guests sip wine, share porch‑light laughter, and settle into heartfelt hospitality. Handcrafted soaps and local connections make every moment intentional. Stay for the story.

A wraparound porch made for lingering, just as it has for generations.

Sip & Savor

Here are a few things to sip & savor when you visit…

Birds Eye Hollow Farm & Distillery is tucked in the woods, where the maple bourbon is smooth and the hot maple‑bacon pizza hits just right. 
Domaine Leseurre pairs French craft with a stunning Keuka Lake view and a staff that's always welcoming, with wines we return for again and again. 
Lake Life Brewery sits an easy walk from the B&B, with good beer, fire‑roasted bites, and a genuinely welcoming vibe we always enjoy together. 

See & Do

Here are a few things to see & do when you visit…

We love the Finger Lakes Boating Museum for the way it brings back old lake days-wooden boats, real stories, and the heart of Keuka's past
The Glenn H. Curtiss Museum carries early machines, local stories, and that old spirit of courage and curiosity. There's something here for everyone.
I've walked Watkins Glen State Park since I was little, and its cool trails and waterfalls still feel honest and familiar every time I go. 

Guest Reviews

Sidney Full

A fabulous B&B with even more fabulous hosts! My husband & I stayed at Maggie and Mike’s B&B for our anniversary and it met all of our wishes. Maggie’s three-course breakfast each morning was 11/10, we will be missing that during the work week. Mike was a lovely “waiter” as he brought the meal out and started our morning with easy conversation and laughter. The home itself was so...

- Sidney Full
Tiffany V.

​We recently enjoyed a wonderful weekend getaway with two other couples at your home. One of the couples stayed with you two years ago, raved about their experience, and we can now see why. ​We were completely blown away by the architecture and how immaculate and perfect every inch of the house was. It's clear that you, Maggie and Mike, have put so much thought and care into the...

- Tiffany V.
Michele Wolniewicz

Dear Maggie & Mike, A simple "Thank You" just isn't enough to say how grateful Gary & I are that we chose your B&B to celebrate our 50th Wedding Anniversary! Our room was spacious and lovely! We enjoyed relaxing on the front porch drinking our morning coffee and then having a delicious breakfast! Maggie your delicious homemade breakfast treats were perfect! Mike we loved our morning of chit-chat &...

- Michele Wolniewicz
Dianna Harrington

This is our 3rd stay (one was under previous ownership) and once again it was stellar. Maggie and Mike are amazing and when you stay, you notice all of the intricate details that make it so special. We stayed in the Library room which has a comfortable king sized bed on the first floor. Beautifully decorated and cozy with a cute reading nook it takes you back to a...

- Dianna Harrington
Beth Meyer

Maggie and Mike are the ultimate hosts. Their B&B is well-appointed with attention to every historical detail of their home. The 9am breakfasts were scrumptious. It was a welcome touch to have coffee service available at 7:30, giving us time to enjoy morning coffee in the peaceful outdoors on the porch, chatting with other guests. A cold bottle of water provided each morning was a welcome bit of thoughtfulness...

- Beth Meyer

Rooms & Suites

# of Rooms: 5

Room Amenities: Antique Furnishings

Explore Rooms & Suites
For information on ADA accessibility for the facility or its rooms, please contact the property directly.

Policies

Smoking Policy: Smoke free

Family Friendly: No

Learn more about Policies of Finger Lakes Bed & Breakfast at Hutton Farm

Food & Wine

Meals Offered: Breakfast

Dining Amenities: Complimentary Early Coffee Tea

Explore Food & Wine

Guest Services

Internet Service: Wireless

Inn Amenities: Hot Breakfast, Free Onsite Parking, Gardens on Property, Wine/Spirits Available

Location Type: Ranch Farm, Small Town/Village

 
 
Select Registry Gift Certificates Shop Now
SL Rewards Logo

Earn Rewards for your Travel

SIGN UP TODAY
Special Offers

packages and
Special Offers

View Offers

Sign Up for The Newsletter

Stay in the know about exclusive offers, travel inspiration, updates, and more from our diverse portfolio.

 
OWNER or INNKEEPER LOGIN

Open feedback form Click Here to request a password reset

For Innkeepers

Owner or Innkeeper Login Learn about Membership Hospitality Industry Vendors Industry Association Partners

About Us

Contact Us Select Rewards Program The Select Registry Difference About The Journal Press Coverage
 

Craft Lodging

Craft Lodging offers authentic and personalized accommodations that showcase local culture and artisanal craftsmanship. Our curated bed and breakfasts, boutique hotels, and inns provide a unique and charming experience, with locally sourced food and personalized recommendations from knowledgeable hosts. Book your stay today to discover the magic of Craft Lodging.

©2026 Select Registry. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy|Terms and Conditions