An intimate adult-only bed & breakfast in the heart of Old Town Key West.
4.8
An intimate adult-only bed & breakfast in the heart of Old Town Key West.
4.8
The Basics
SELECT REGISTRY MEMBER SINCE 2015
The Mermaid & The Alligator is a serene, adult-only bed & breakfast in the heart of Old Town Key West. Offering nine beautifully decorated guest rooms, made-to-order breakfast daily, lush gardens, and impeccable service, it is a destination for the discerning traveler.
In the Know
- Celebrate sunset from Mallory Square
- The view from the Key West Lighthouse is amazing
- A stroll through the Key West Cemetery is a history lesson
- Nancy Forrester's Secret Garden is a hidden gem
Stay for the Story
A stay at The Mermaid & The Alligator will have guests feeling as if they have stepped back in time. The architecture of the historic home, carefully curated artwork throughout, and lush gardens are reminiscent of a bygone era in Key West.
Sip & Savor
Here are a few things to sip & savor when you visit…
Enjoy the oceanfront setting at Louies Backyard
Experience life like a local at Azur
An award winning wine list and live music at Blue Heaven Key West
See & Do
Here are a few things to see & do when you visit…
Be sure to visit the Hemingway Home and Museum
Walk among hundreds of living butterflies and colorful birds at the Key West Butterfly and Nature Conservancy
Shop, dine and enjoy the culture of Duval Street - the heartbeat of Key West
Packages and Special Offers
VALID THROUGH: Sep 30 2025
Hot Summer Special
Stay three consecutive nights and receive a fourth night for free June 1 - September 30, 2025. This offer is valid on new reservations only and you must book directly on our website or by calling us at 305-294-1894....See More
The Mermaid & The Alligator
Key West, FL
Guest Reviews
My husband and I stayed here for our honeymoon in January. I had been wanting to try The Mermaid and The Alligator for years now and I'm so happy that I finally got the chance to. The property itself is so naturally stunning. The garden is so quaint and peaceful and such a wonderful place to enjoy breakfast and a cup of coffee in the mornings. One of my...See More
- Jenna Zimmerman
My husband and I booked the Caribbean King Suite room for our honeymoon and it was fabulous. We were blown away by the property and the proximity to everything. Breakfast was served from 8:30 to 10:30 and was made fresh to order. There was always a spread of fruit, pastries and cereal. The staff were wonderful! Diana couldn’t have been more pleasant. Snacks and drinks were available at our...See More
- Eva Sweeney
We stayed here for 3 nights and it was truly a wonderful experience. The breakfasts are so, so good, the lady in the kitchen is very nice and our breakfasts were presented very nicely. There is also a breakfast bar with assorted breads, cereal ,yogurt, and these great fruit cups. We stayed in the Garden Room and then moved to the Caribbean King where we had our own private...See More
- mona schleser
Beautifully maintained lush hideaway. Stayed for 4 nights in the Garden Room. Enjoyed every minute. Great location. Walking distance to some wonderful restaurants. Staff were friendly and helpful with reservations or recommendations.Room was thoroughly cleaned daily. Breakfast was a buffett along with a hot plate specialty. A refrigerator stocked with a variety of beverages and snacks were available 24/7. Happy hour daily with wine, cheese, salami and grapes completed...See More
- Cheri Durko
This is a very comfortable and accommodating place to stay. The staff was wonderful and the location was great for walking distance to so much. Great 1st experience & looking forward to a return visit.
- Dawn Mitchell
Rooms & Suites
# of Rooms: 9
Room Amenities: Air Conditioning, Bathrobes, Hair Dryer, Alarm Clocks, Antique Furnishings
Explore Rooms & SuitesFor information on ADA accessibility for the facility or its rooms, please contact the property directly.
Policies
Smoking Policy: Smoke free
Family Friendly: No
Learn moreFood & Wine
Meals Offered: Breakfast
Special Diets Accommodated: Yes
Restaurant on Premises: No
Dining Amenities: Complimentary Afternoon Tea/Refreshments, Complimentary Beverages, Complimentary Early Coffee Tea, Evening Cocktails, Special Diets Accommodated
Explore Food & WineGuest Services
Internet Service: Wireless
Front Desk/Security: Onsite
Corporate Rates: No
Inn Amenities: Cabins/Cottages Available, Concierge Services, Free Onsite Parking, Full House Rental Available, Gardens on Property, LGBTQI+ Friendly, National Historic Registry, Spa Service, Swimming Pool
Explore Guest ServicesThe Journal
The Best Places to Visit in January in the USA
January ushers in a breath of fresh air for everyone....
READ ON
Soak up the Sun on the Ultimate Florida Road Trip
10 of the Best Places to Stop on a Florida...
READ ON
National Park Getaways to Avoid the Crowds
There are 62 National Parks in the United States. No...
READ ON
Escape the Winter blues in Key West Florida
Warmth, Sun, & Beaches Are Waiting! With wintry weather setting...
READ ON
Experience the Coastal Charms of Key West This Winter
The Perfect Antidote to a Cold Winter If you want...
READ ONLocation Type: Coastal, Small Town/Village
